Why Zack Polanski is Wrong About the Right of Nations to Exist

Why Zack Polanski is Wrong About the Right of Nations to Exist

Political discourse has a habit of descending into philosophical abstraction just when concrete answers are required. When Green Party figurehead Zack Polanski faced direct questioning about whether Israel has a right to exist, he didn't offer a standard political talking point. Instead, he pivoted to a sweeping metaphysical claim: nations don't have rights, only people do.

It sounds clever on a morning talk show. But it fundamentally misunderstands how international law, human safety, and national sovereignty actually function in the real world. You might also find this related coverage insightful: Why Hurricane Isaias Caught Everyone Off Guard.

The Flaw in Separating People from States

Polanski argued that while Israelis and Palestinians possess an inherent right to exist, the apparatus of a state or border does not. On paper, you can separate the abstract concept of a government from the flesh-and-blood human beings who wake up under its jurisdiction. In practice, that distinction is a luxury reserved for political theorists.

Human rights don't float around in a vacuum. Throughout modern history, individuals secure their safety, property, and cultural survival precisely through sovereign self-determination. Stripping a nation of its recognized right to exist while claiming to support the people inside it is a dangerous sleight of hand. Without a sovereign state to protect them, vulnerable populations have historically found out just how worthless an abstract "right to exist" really is when no government has the duty or power to defend them. As reported in recent coverage by Associated Press, the implications are notable.

This is especially poignant for Jewish people, whose generational trauma is tied directly to statelessness. When political leaders casually dismiss the legitimacy of Israel's statehood under the guise of philosophical pacifism, they ignore the physical reality that state sovereignty is the only barrier keeping millions from persecution.

Singling Out Israel for Unique Philosophical Scrutiny

Let's address the elephant in the room. Politicians rarely get backed into a corner and asked if France, Canada, or Japan has a fundamental right to exist. Those nations are taken as permanent fixtures of the global map.

Yet Israel faces a unique ontological cross-examination. Debating whether a specific nation-state should exist at all is rarely applied neutrally; it's deployed as a rhetorical weapon against Zionism and Jewish self-determination. When leaders try to split hairs by saying they oppose the state while loving the people, they are playing a dangerous semantic game. You cannot separate the two when the physical destruction or dismantling of the state would spell immediate catastrophe for the population living within it.

Borders Are Messy, But They Matter

Critics of modern nation-states love to point out that borders are artificial constructs born of historical conflicts, treaties, and colonial paperwork. Polanski dismissed these debates as esoteric semantics.

Sure, borders are human inventions. Almost every border on Earth was drawn with blood, ink, and compromise. But dismissing national sovereignty as a mere fiction ignores what happens when borders dissolve. Chaos follows. Power vacuums swallow minorities.

If we apply Polanski's logic universally, no country has moral legitimacy. Does the United Kingdom have a right to exist? Does any post-colonial nation in the Americas or the Middle East? If you answer no across the board, you aren't offering a coherent foreign policy—you're advocating for geopolitical anarchy. If you only apply that standard to Israel, you're practicing a selective double standard.

Facing Reality Over Rhetoric

We need politicians who deal in reality, not university-seminar talking points. Conflating legitimate criticism of a government's current policies with a denial of the nation's right to exist destroys any chance of a stable resolution.

Israel exists. Millions of human beings live, work, and build their futures there. Pretending that its statehood is just an optional philosophical debate doesn't bring peace closer—it only signals that the security of certain populations is negotiable. That isn't progress. It's just old prejudice dressed up in new vocabulary.

BM

Bella Mitchell

Bella Mitchell has built a reputation for clear, engaging writing that transforms complex subjects into stories readers can connect with and understand.