Why New Works at American Ballet Theatre Struggle Beside Ashton and Balanchine

Why New Works at American Ballet Theatre Struggle Beside Ashton and Balanchine

Walk into the Metropolitan Opera House during American Ballet Theatre's summer season, and you'll feel an immediate shift in the room depending on what's on the playbill. When a newly commissioned work hits the stage, the audience sits politely. They clap at the right moments. They admire the lighting and the athleticism.

Then the curtain rises on a classic by Frederick Ashton or George Balanchine, and the entire theater wakes up.

It isn't just nostalgia talking. For decades, ballet fans and critics have watched contemporary choreographers try to match the structural brilliance and musical instinct of the 20th century's greatest dance makers. At American Ballet Theatre (ABT), where mixed-repertory programs intentionally place brand-new commissions right next to established masterpieces, that contrast becomes impossible to ignore.

The Structural Problem With Modern Ballet Commissions

Most contemporary ballet commissions suffer from a basic flaw. They prioritize concept over choreography.

When a choreographer walks into the studio today, they often arrive with a dense program note, a moody lighting plot, and a commissioned score that sounds more like film ambience than dance music. The dancers execute astonishing physical feats. Legs go higher than ever. Turns are faster. Extensions look superhuman.

Yet ten minutes after the curtain falls, you can't remember a single phrase of movement.

Compare that to how Balanchine and Ashton built dances. Neither man needed a three-paragraph explanation in the playbill to tell you what a piece was about. Their meaning lived inside the steps themselves. If you watch Balanchine's Theme and Variations—a work ABT has performed since its premiere in 1947—every musical accent in Tchaikovsky's score gets a physical answer on stage. A sharp violin pizzicato matches a crisp piqué. A swelling orchestral phrase opens into sweeping grand allegro across the stage.

Ashton worked differently, yet with the exact same devotion to musical architecture. In pieces like The Dream or Symphonic Variations, he focused on the upper body, the curve of the spine, and intricate, rapid footwork that looks effortless until you try to count the beats. Ashton understood how to make stillness speak just as loudly as a triple tour en l'air.

New works at ABT often mistake constant motion for dramatic urgency. Dancers run on, twist into contorted partnering lifts, roll across the floor, and run off. Without contrast or stillness, everything blurs into visual white noise.

Why ABT's Dancers Look Different in Classic Repertory

ABT has always been known as a company of stars and dramatic storytellers rather than a uniform ensemble with a single house style. Unlike New York City Ballet, which trains its dancers from childhood at the School of American Ballet specifically to handle Balanchine's speed and attack, ABT pulls top talent from all over the world.

Because of that diverse training, ABT dancers sometimes look slightly unmoored in contemporary works that lack clear stylistic rules. When a choreographer asks for "organic movement" or loose, pedestrian gestures, classically trained virtuosos can look self-conscious. You can see them working to shed their natural polish.

Put those exact same dancers into Ashton or Balanchine, and something clicks.

The strict parameters of classical technique actually set them free. In Balanchine's Allegro Brillante or Ballet Imperial, the choreography demands total commitment to speed, off-balance phrasing, and razor-sharp musicality. There's nowhere to hide. The steps push the dancers past their comfort zones, forcing them to attack the space with abandon.

In Ashton's repertory, ABT's theatrical instincts shine. Ashton loved nuanced characterization and genuine human warmth. When ABT principals take on roles in La Fille mal gardée or Les Patineurs, they stop trying to look "modern" and start acting through classical phrasing. Their epaulement—the subtle angling of the shoulders and head—suddenly comes alive.

The Music Factor Nobody Wants to Admit

Let's be honest about why so many new ballets fall flat. The music isn't danceable.

Balanchine famously said, "See the music, hear the dance." He spent years studying piano and composition at the Petrograd Conservatory before he ever became a major choreographer. He could read an orchestral score like a novel. Ashton, while less formally trained in music theory, possessed an uncanny ear for phrasing and dramatic pacing, leaning on composers like Mendelssohn, Prokofiev, and César Franck.

Today, many new commissions rely on newly written scores that avoid clear melody, steady pulse, or recognizable rhythmic structure. Composers write atmospheric textures, drones, and irregular time signatures. While that might sound intriguing in a concert hall, it leaves dancers counting endlessly in their heads instead of riding a musical wave.

When dancers have to count every single beat just to stay together, the audience feels the math. The magic evaporates. Great choreography needs music that propels the body forward, creating tension and release that an audience feels in their gut even if they've never taken a ballet class.

What Mixed Bills Reveal About Artistic Direction

Programming a mixed-repertory evening is one of the hardest jobs in the dance world. Artistic directors have to balance donor expectations, ticket sales, dancer development, and the push to keep ballet relevant as a living art form.

Under both former artistic director Kevin McKenzie and current artistic director Susan Jaffe, ABT has worked hard to commission new voices, particularly female choreographers and artists from outside the traditional ballet establishment. That mission matters. Ballet cannot survive as a museum art form that only revives 19th-century story ballets and mid-20th-century masterpieces.

Still, placing a fragile new work on the same program as Ashton or Balanchine is a brutal stress test.

Think about what happens to an audience member's brain during a triple bill. If the evening opens with Balanchine's Serenade or Ashton's Monotones II, the bar for craft, proportion, and emotional resonance is immediately set at the ceiling. Everything that follows gets measured against that standard.

Many contemporary pieces simply don't have the structural stamina to survive that comparison. A ten-minute pas de deux that might look promising in a small studio showing at New York City Center suddenly looks thin and undercooked on the massive stage of the Metropolitan Opera House. That stage swallows small ideas whole. If a choreographer doesn't know how to move a corps de ballet across a vast space with clear geometric patterns, the stage looks empty.

Balanchine and Ashton were masters of spatial geometry. Watch how Balanchine shifts diagonal lines in Symphony in C or how Ashton frames a solo dancer with subtle groupings in Birthday Offering. Every corner of the stage feels intentional.

How Ballet Companies Can Fix the Commission Pipeline

If major companies like ABT want new ballets to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with 20th-century classics, the commissioning process needs a serious rethink. Right now, the system rushes choreographers and prioritizes novelty over craft.

Here is what actually moves the needle when building lasting repertory:

  1. Give choreographers real studio time before the premiere. Too often, a guest choreographer gets three or four weeks with exhausted dancers who are simultaneously rehearsing Swan Lake and Giselle. Masterpieces aren't built in a rush. Companies need to invest in multi-year workshops where choreographers can test ideas, throw out what doesn't work, and refine transitions without opening-night panic.
  2. Stop treating classical vocabulary like a dirty word. Many emerging choreographers feel pressured to invent a completely new movement language to prove they are original. That's backwards. Balanchine and Ashton didn't throw out classical technique—they bent it, accelerated it, and pushed its proportions until it looked brand new. Mastering the rules of turnout, beats, and classical line gives a choreographer far more expressive range than generic contemporary floorwork.
  3. Pair choreographers with scores that actually swing. Whether using existing orchestral works or commissioning new music, the score has to breathe. Rhythm, counterpoint, and melodic phrasing give dancers something to push against.
  4. Bring back successful new works for second and third seasons. One of the biggest mistakes in ballet today is the "one-and-done" commission. A ballet rarely reaches its full potential during its premiere run. Dancers need time to settle into the steps, find the phrasing, and make the roles their own. Balanchine routinely revised his ballets years after their premieres.

Practical Ways to Watch a Mixed Repertory Program

Next time you grab tickets for an ABT mixed bill—or any major ballet company pairing new commissions with Ashton or Balanchine—change how you watch the stage. You'll immediately see why certain works endure while others fade by intermission.

Pay attention to the corps de ballet, not just the principal couple in the center. In a great ballet, the ensemble isn't just standing around as human scenery; they are actively framing the action and echoing the musical themes. Notice how dancers enter and exit the stage. Weak choreography relies on awkward blackouts or clunky walking transitions, while master choreographers make entrances and exits look like natural extensions of the music.

Most importantly, close your eyes for ten seconds during a piece and just listen to the orchestra, then open them again. If the movement on stage looks like a direct physical translation of what you're hearing, you're watching real craft at work. If the dancers look like they're moving to a completely different soundtrack in another room, you've spotted the exact trap that sinks so many modern ballets.

JJ

Julian Jones

Julian Jones is an award-winning writer whose work has appeared in leading publications. Specializes in data-driven journalism and investigative reporting.