Why A Firing Squad Execution Is The Most Honest Punishment Left

Why A Firing Squad Execution Is The Most Honest Punishment Left

The headlines are clutching their pearls over the return of the firing squad. Every mainstream outlet is framing this as a medieval regression, a barbaric slip backward into the dark ages of penal policy. They want you to look at the machinery of state-sanctioned death through a lens of squeamish hypocrisy.

Let us dispense with the sanctimony.

The mainstream argument against the firing squad relies on a comfortable delusion. We are told that lethal injection is somehow civilized because it smells like a hospital and requires a curtain to hide the mechanics. We spend decades debating the pharmacology of midazolam and potassium chloride, pretending that we are performing a medical procedure rather than ending a human life.

That is the real barbarism. Dressing up state execution in scrubs does not make it humane. It makes it cowardly.

When the state kills a prisoner via lethal injection, it outsources the moral weight to a sterile cocktail manufactured in secret, administered by anonymous technicians behind closed doors. It is sanitized for the consumer's comfort. It allows the public and the policymakers to wash their hands of the violence they authorized, muttering platitudes about dignity while ignoring the botched venous lines, the prolonged convulsions, and the procedural opacity that turns capital punishment into a bureaucratic horror show.

The firing squad strips away the medical theater. It forces everyone involved—the executioners, the witnesses, the state, and by extension, the citizenry—to look directly at the mechanics of state power.

There is no hiding behind a curtain. There is no masquerade of healing.

Let us look at the mechanics honestly. A rifle volley is instantaneous. The physics of kinetic impact destroy the brain stem and the central nervous system faster than pain signals can register on a conscious level. Compare that to the documented failures of lethal injection, where prisoners have languished for hours while executioners scrambled for viable veins, and the statistical reality becomes impossible to ignore.

Data compiled by legal scholars and penal reform advocates alike show that lethal injection carries a significantly higher rate of botched executions than older methods, including electrocution and shooting. Yet, we cling to the lethal injection protocol not because it is humane, but because it is quiet. It offends our aesthetic sensibilities less.

That is not justice. That is interior design.

Critics argue that bringing back the firing squad normalizes state violence. This gets the causality precisely backward. State violence is already normalized through endless foreign interventions, militarized domestic policing, and a penal system that locks millions away in conditions that defy basic human decency. The firing squad does not create state violence; it simply refuses to conceal it.

If a government holds the ultimate authority to execute its citizens, that authority should be exercised in the clear light of day, without the protective camouflage of medical terminology. If the act is too gruesome to be watched, perhaps the act should not be committed at all. But pretending that a lethal injection is somehow morally superior because it looks like a nap is an insult to logic.

The debate over execution methods is a distraction from the fundamental failure of capital punishment as a deterrent or a tool of public safety. But as long as the machinery of capital punishment grinds forward, demanding aesthetic comfort from an inherently violent act is the height of bad faith.

Let the state own its violence. Drop the medical charade.

A bullet requires no disguise. Neither should the state.

BM

Bella Mitchell

Bella Mitchell has built a reputation for clear, engaging writing that transforms complex subjects into stories readers can connect with and understand.